Showing posts with label Drosscape. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Drosscape. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Changes


So here I am, returned from a glorious honeymoon in Portugal. Aside from getting robbed of our remaining cash on our last day while we were away from our hotel room, Lisbon and Madeira offered a perfect spot to start a marriage. But of course, even on vacation, I found myself thinking about our exotic surroundings and trying to dissect how a settlement with hundreds of years on anywhere in America has evolved and adjusted to the realities of modern land use needs. Our first stop, Lisbon, had all of what an unindoctrinated American would expect from an "Old World" city. Tight cobblestone roads of the Alfama and Bairro Alto districts captured the bygone times of medieval Europe. We walked the ruins of the St. George's Castle, which overlooked the city, and explored the Belem Tower, a few miles outside of the city center, which was the demarcation point for countless voyages during the Age of Discovery. But it was a discovery that I made in our hotel which was most intriguing to me.

Rummaging through the hotel library, I came across a flier for the Lisbon International Triennale of Architecture, which will be held until the end of July. Unfortunately, I only read the pamphlet after we had left the city. Using "Urban Voids" as its main theme, the symposium's primary mission is to discuss and propose solutions to rectify what the literature calls "spots of 'non-city,' absent places, ignored or not in use anymore, aliens or survivors to any structuring urban plan." Like the "Drosscape" previously discussed in my post dated December 5, 2006, the collection of thinkers drawn to this event will examine ways to reuse and adapt those parcels and locales within cities that have fallen into disuse. When I think about the "Urban Voids" of Lisbon, I can recall those locations we traversed that needed additional consideration and attention. My wife and I left Lisbon with a sense that the city was one definitely worth exploring, but one that did not necessarily require a return trip. Sure, this is a different measure than one to determine the actual vitality of a city, but it does provide some indication as the work that the capital of Portugal can still do to improve on the centuries that have come before.

Moving over to Madeira, and the wonderful vistas that exude from its jagged coast and rugged topography, and the beautiful blue ocean that hugs its shores, this locale brought a sense of new discovery to us. At the same time, I saw many of the same questions to answer regarding "Urban Voids." Sure, Funchal, the major city on the volcanic island, is a beautiful, picture perfect postcard of a resort town, down to the overhead cable car system that take tourists over its wonderful streets below. Gorgeous, if not small vacation homes shove their way up the hills that lead out of town up into the heart of the island. But beneath the luster of the commercial center, where the day we walked its streets a line of classic automobiles were primed for a road rally, was there more that could be done?

I suppose the thoughts that crossed my mind most were about the potential of these places. Notwithstanding their existing beauty, as a land use professional, I couldn't resist what more they could be. In both locations, we were afforded only a very small sample of what it meant to be in "Lisbon" and "Funchal." But of what we saw, we were still left with, "is there more?" Maybe it's that ingrained American outlook on things that pushed us to ask for more. But if the great European minds thinking about issues involving the built environment are also asking this same question, maybe it is a more fundamental pursuit, one that crosses national borders and language and cultural differences. It is that inherent drive of optimism that continues to change and reshape the world around us. Almost on the order of the desire to repaint the walls in your house, just because you want something different, the need to update the place you live in is a prerequisite to remaining a vital part of the outside world. Changes need to be marked with great fanfare, just as my wife and I did in glorious fashion as we walked the streets of Portugal. Perhaps this underlying, fundamental movement towards change will entice us back to the country, to rediscover it all over again.

Thursday, March 22, 2007

Clean Slate


For the past week or so I’ve been contending with one of those things that makes you feel, or tells you that you are, old. My back has turned on me, forcing me to inch around my apartment, walking like Frankenstein’s monster -- when I can actually stand. If anything, it has allowed me the chance to watch a lot of Hawaii Five-O, and in between, do a bit of reading. One of my choices was the Historical Atlas of the United States, by Derek Hayes. Studying the evolution of the North American continent from sparsely-inhabited to open space-challenged in a period of five hundred years, the maps and Hayes’ narration got me to thinking about what it would have been like to be around to see the fledgling New Amsterdam settlement, huddled against the southern tip of Manhattan Island, with pastures to the north and oyster shells piled on the shores. What would mission-era Los Angeles have been like, with the expansive basin undeveloped between the small settlement and the shores of the Pacific miles away, with no Wilshire Boulevard or Interstate 10 to connect the two? How about walking the Great Plains, unable to see above the native prairie grasses? Or the Chicago River before it was turned green each year for St. Patrick’s Day? These thoughts have always fascinated me, and the whole idea of starting a city from scratch has intrigued me, if not called me to buy a copy of SimCity.

City building is a continual human endeavor, even today. There will always be the polishing and tinkering performed on all modern cities. Metaphorically, the striving for the “new” will never end. Look at the west side of Chicago, which when I was in college there in the mid-nineties, it was a place to avoid. Now, with the influx of gentrifying forces, it is the place to be, particularly with the razing of Cabrini-Green, one of the most infamous public housing communities in the country. Of course, not everyone has benefited. Nonetheless, the march continues on. Likewise, in the thicket of Long Island, Charles Wang, owner of the New York Islanders and founder of Computer Associates, along with his real estate partner Scott Rechler, are looking to transform the hamlets of Old Bethpage and Plainview with a 166-acre parcel they seek to develop with a number of uses.

But what about entirely new cities rising from the ground in a world where it seems that potential sites have pretty much been exhausted? For instance, about sixty miles north of Los Angeles, along Interstate 5, three massive projects on the existing 270,000 acre Tejon Ranch are making their way through the land use and environmental approval processes. The three developments together would comprise about 50,000 acres, leaving the majority of the ranch intact. However, the magnitude of such a project has raised eyebrows in a region well acquainted with swallowing huge swaths of land for new development. The cornerstone project, Centennial, would include 23,000 homes and all of the amenities required to support a community of approximately 70,000 people. The second project, deemed Tejon Mountain Village, would include 3,500 homes catering towards the second home set. Finally, the third parcel would involve the construction of industrial park facilities. Literally from the ground up, a new city would be born. The approach is well in keeping with Alan Berger’s Drosscape view of urban expansion, where he charts the growing prevalence of communities about 50 miles beyond existing metropolises to serve the distribution needs of our national and international transportation network. (See prior post dated December 5, 2006). The Tejon Ranch plan is also in line with another familiar trend.

This next stage in city building is in some ways an attempt to provide what suburbs did in the last century -– provide that enclave separate and apart from the central city. With Americans increasingly accepting difficult commutes, living 60 miles from the office does not seem out of the question for many. If cheaper housing and quality amenities are present, the dream of “escape” has been granted again. When new settlers first planted themselves on Manhattan, and on the banks of the Chicago River and in the Los Angeles Basin, in some ways they also sought such an “escape,” to forge their own paths, and create something new. For me, I’m perfectly happy accepting my fate of being "old," at least when it comes to my choice of address. Following the trail of millions of others over the last five hundred years, I'm content to remain planted in Brooklyn. Not to mention, my back shouts to me to preserve it a bit longer, and avoid the sixty-mile commute each way.

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

Drosscape


I just finished a fabulous book called Drosscape: Wasting Land in Urban America, by Alan Berger. Published by the Princeton Architectural Press, the book just came out earlier this year. Berger, an associate professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Design, states the case for redevelopment, particularly in the context of “dross,” or wasted land within the built environment of metropolitan areas. Berger calls for the adaptive reuse of properties that have fallen into disuse on account of deindustrialization, post-Ford economic shifts and technological innovation. Sites contaminated by industrial processes, dying shopping malls, old landfills, decommissioned military installations, areas bordering infrastructural improvements, redundant sports stadiums, and transition areas for residential communities are just a few of the targeted parcels.

Berger makes the astonishing argument, which makes the pro- versus anti-sprawl debate irrelevant, that “there is no growth without waste and that urban growth and dross go hand in hand.” Comparing the growth process of metropolitan areas to any other living organism, Berger asserts that just as a living thing grows, cities produce waste in their pursuit to expand. “Dross” is an unavoidable byproduct of metropolitan growth. Nonetheless, Berger notes with great enthusiasm that these underutilized areas are great opportunities for designers, not to mention developers and other land use professionals, to return these parcels to productivity within the modern economy.

The greatest virtue of Berger’s work, however, is the phenomenal collection of aerial photographs that he has compiled while hanging out of an airplane high above his targets. Over half of the work is comprised of Berger’s capturing of the sites he discusses in the text. Berger chronicles the shifting dynamics in cities today by concretely showing how Americans use the land they occupy. New residential units, malls and warehouse facilities sprout on the far edges of existing communities. Central cities attempt to cope with this movement by redefining its place in the metropolitan area’s overall future. Berger supports these photographic examples with statistics displayed in easy-to-decipher graphs.

Essentially, Berger advocates using redevelopment to return the “dross” to the mainstream of the built environment. He notes the Kelo decision as an occurrence “for better and worse” but he misses the finer points of the Supreme Court’s decision. Nonetheless, Berger firmly stands behind its overarching vote for municipal power to carry out his “drosscape” agenda. Despite its glossing over of the existing land use process, a nagging problem with redundancies in the text and its calls for change without specifics commonly found in academic tracts, Drosscape offers a wonderful overview of the state of affairs in modern American land use. The vivid pictures alone are worth the price. It also demonstrates once again the power that land use holds over American psyches – even those deep and meaningful psyches that walk the greens of Cambridge, Massachusetts.