Thursday, December 28, 2006

Consumption Junction


After another successful holiday season, where we've collected and given piles of loot to one another, it seems as good a time as any to reflect on this acquisitive culture in which we find ourselves. The spark that brought me to this topic was a wholesome story my fiance and I picked up on a Toronto talk show a few days before Christmas as we drove along the New York Thruway. As they explained to the enthralled host, a couple who had lived many years in the bustle of Toronto decided to pick up their belongings, leave their families and head for the "great north" in Yellowknife, Northwest Territories. Despite the remote nature of the settlement, the husband and wife team expressed no regrets for their decision. She took a job to study the thawing permafrost in the area, and he seemed to have a lot of extra time on hand to pursue his hobbies. She touted her five-minute commute, by foot, to the office -- ten if she stopped to window shop. He lamented the brief visit back to the "big city," and yearned for a speedy return back to his new utopia.

The quaint Canadian couple, along with our cross-country travels a few weeks before, got me thinking about America's urban-oriented mentality, and how most of us (since most of us live in cities and suburbs) will never know what it's truly like to live the "rural way of life." Sure, new developments on the urban fringe attempt to recreate this existence by incorporating the natural environment, be it prairie or forest land, into the residential and commercial structures that rise from the soil. Names of new places evoke what had to be removed to permit us to move in. But living in Yellowknife is still very different from buying into a new townhouse development in central New Jersey.

This divergence in lifestyle choice is clear, but it is not the end of the story. As mentioned last time, no matter how sleepy or "empty" their environs, Americans have learned to make productive use of property, even if it does not have skyscrapers rising above the surface, and subways running below it. If people are present, electric lines must be strung, roads must be built, and septic tanks must be dug. Residents must have a source of water, and they inevitably produce a stream of refuse that must find a home separate from the settlement. Even pastoral farms must have irrigation systems and gas-powered machinery to plant and harvest their products. There may be less people populating rural expanses, but there are people there nonetheless. The consumption of materials, resulting in waste products, is, at its most mundane level, the human condition.

So when that couple from Yellowknife recounts life in that "slower" part of the world, it's hard to overlook the fact that they enjoy many of the same "necessities" of modern human life, down to their satellite cable keeping them connected to what's happening to the South. Land use is land use, be it in midtown Manhattan or the Northwest Territories. There may be less people in their humble settlement, but the consumption mentality remains, down to the Yellowknife couple's window shopping on the way to work. And in this season where we try to find common bonds that unite us all, land use, oddly enough, is one of those connections. The universality of the land use process, which is how we decide to organize our settlements, makes it a common question for all of us stationed on this planet, wherever that might be. This is perhaps not the most heart-warming sentiment for the season, but, take a drive down the street you live on and see the garbage bag upon garbage bag of wrapping paper after Christmas. Viewing such a spectacle shows that it is the day-to-day realities of our existence that ties us tightly together, and brings us together to live in towns and cities strewn across the continent.

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

The Open Road


After thirteen days, twelve roadside motels, a speeding ticket or two, countless meals ranging from mediocre to just plain scary, and an experience that can never be forgotten, my fiance and I have completed our over 4,000-mile journey across this great nation. From Los Angeles to New York, with a detour up the Pacific coast to Seattle, we saw that what it means to be an "American" can mean almost an infinite number of permutations. In San Francisco, Portland and Seattle we saw vibrant city centers occupied by earnest city dwellers. Aided by geography and land use planning, these towns have preserved their core settlements, despite the pull of sprawl impacting all three. Even Portland, a model of land use efficiency, has Nike's world headquarters stationed on its outskirts in suburban Beaverton. Ellensburg, Washington is a sleepy town along Interstate 90 that survives thanks to the influx of spending power of Central Washington University and its students. We passed a night in Gillette, Wyoming, which the denizens happily tout as the coal capital of the nation. Mount Rushmore, and the tourist-dependent Keystone, South Dakota, at its entrance, mine the Black Hills for modern-day sources of income from the land. We drove along the edge of the behemoth that is Chicago, and observed the aggressive push of the metropolis into the Illinois prairie.

The examples were endless across this nation, of people adapting the land where they have settled to a hospitable and profitable place to live. What I came to realize was that no matter what the land offered, its inhabitants have found a way to make "productive" use of it. Even out in the expanses of South Dakota and Minnesota that we drove across, the plots have been subdivided into separate tracts whose owners cultivate the soil for agricultural purposes. In the grasslands of Wyoming, the federal government has leased these lands for grazing by cattle, sheep, llamas and any other domesticated animal seen fit. In Oregon, we wandered off the Pacific Coast Highway to seek out a fish hatchery, and saw fishermen parked along the side of the road, standing in the stream that ran along side. Even in the Crow Nation's reservation in Montana, cell towers rise along the roadway where on either side it appears there is "nothing."

This of course is not meant to imply that every square inch of the continent is occupied, but it is to say that land use takes many forms. Most of the press and attention does go towards what's happening on the urban fringe, and to big developments meant to revitalize city centers. But in all that "in between" space between the two coasts is an enormous amount of activity that cannot be ignored. Putting aside the metropolises that aren't located on an ocean, the world that is rural America offers a fascinating glimpse into why people choose to live in places that aren't hot real estate markets. Each place provides an attractive reason, whatever it may be. Otherwise, the settlement would have completely crumbled, just as it has in western "ghost towns" that some attempt to revive as tourist attractions.

If anything, our excursion across the nation reminded me of the richness of this country and its people, and the need to keep that in mind whenever seeking to explain the collective decisions by this country. From a land use perspective, it opens up for me a new interest in rural land use, and how it interacts with metropolitan pressures. Coming from "the city," it reminds me that in my future work, rural concerns are just as critical as those that impact the existing built environment, because the rural world is as much a part of the economy and the debate as the urban realm. If only the press would realize that as well. Apparently all it takes is a two-week sojourn across the continent.

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Fees, Glorious Fees


One of the less heroic chores during my days as a land use attorney was making sure that before we submitted a land use application with a municipality, the application fees and escrow amounts to serve as retainers for board professional reviews were computed properly. Some were straightforward affairs, requiring flat fees for projects. However, other localities’ formulas required the combined mathematical powers of our office to arrive at the correct figures. Sometimes it would take careful conversations with the town to ensure accuracy, and perhaps haggle for a better price. Constructing overly complex computations based on a variety of factors – square footage of construction, lot areas, etc. – town officials would take great glee at spotting our “errors” to extract additional funds from the applicant. Those situations would lead to the query often lamented by lawyers: “Is this why I went to law school?”

Clear for a time from those moments of frustration, I recently read an article from the Los Angeles Times about the cry from builders over an increase in “impact fees,” or payments required by municipalities and other governmental units to finance new services and infrastructure required by new development. As one builder from the piece notes, “[t]he added costs have made many new homes unaffordable.” At best, this statement is pure hyperbole. Although different from land use application fees and escrows, impact fees derive from the land use process, and often are tied to approvals as conditions that must be met to permit the drawing of building permits. If builders could not sell their products, they would simply stop producing them.

The push and pull over impact fees boils down the issue of who should pay for the needs created by new development within a community. Municipalities argue that existing residents and businesses already pay taxes. To require additional payments from these constituencies would not only threaten local politicians at the ballot box, it would be inherently unfair, imposing a double taxation on the community. On the other end of the debate, new residents (and the builders who pass along the costs to them) argue that they are being discriminated against, and that the old residents benefit from new roads, more firemen and increased funding for schools just as much as the new inhabitants.

In the end, as is the case with any change, all parties have to pay. New residents pay, as part of their purchase price into the community, for the infrastructure and services the town will provide. The town pays by having to grow its bureaucracy to accommodate the needs of the newcomers. The existing residents pay by losing some of the qualities that attracted them to their homes or places of business in the first place. To require monetary payment from the consumers of new development may be the most affordable cost amongst the respective groups “impacted” by the new construction.

But all of the affected parties also receive a benefit for the changes that come from new development. Obviously, the new residents have paid to enter because they receive the benefits that the town has to offer. The town itself will increase its tax base, and no doubt the prestige of being the home for new businesses and homes. Finally, the existing residents will be enriched by the influx of new personalities and ideas into the community. There is a reason for the fees. In the end, they are more often than not well worth every penny.


Next time, I'll delve into the journey my fiance and I just completed -- a two-week odyssey on the road from Los Angeles to New York -- and the facinating ways in which we use and occupy the North American continent.

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

Drosscape


I just finished a fabulous book called Drosscape: Wasting Land in Urban America, by Alan Berger. Published by the Princeton Architectural Press, the book just came out earlier this year. Berger, an associate professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Design, states the case for redevelopment, particularly in the context of “dross,” or wasted land within the built environment of metropolitan areas. Berger calls for the adaptive reuse of properties that have fallen into disuse on account of deindustrialization, post-Ford economic shifts and technological innovation. Sites contaminated by industrial processes, dying shopping malls, old landfills, decommissioned military installations, areas bordering infrastructural improvements, redundant sports stadiums, and transition areas for residential communities are just a few of the targeted parcels.

Berger makes the astonishing argument, which makes the pro- versus anti-sprawl debate irrelevant, that “there is no growth without waste and that urban growth and dross go hand in hand.” Comparing the growth process of metropolitan areas to any other living organism, Berger asserts that just as a living thing grows, cities produce waste in their pursuit to expand. “Dross” is an unavoidable byproduct of metropolitan growth. Nonetheless, Berger notes with great enthusiasm that these underutilized areas are great opportunities for designers, not to mention developers and other land use professionals, to return these parcels to productivity within the modern economy.

The greatest virtue of Berger’s work, however, is the phenomenal collection of aerial photographs that he has compiled while hanging out of an airplane high above his targets. Over half of the work is comprised of Berger’s capturing of the sites he discusses in the text. Berger chronicles the shifting dynamics in cities today by concretely showing how Americans use the land they occupy. New residential units, malls and warehouse facilities sprout on the far edges of existing communities. Central cities attempt to cope with this movement by redefining its place in the metropolitan area’s overall future. Berger supports these photographic examples with statistics displayed in easy-to-decipher graphs.

Essentially, Berger advocates using redevelopment to return the “dross” to the mainstream of the built environment. He notes the Kelo decision as an occurrence “for better and worse” but he misses the finer points of the Supreme Court’s decision. Nonetheless, Berger firmly stands behind its overarching vote for municipal power to carry out his “drosscape” agenda. Despite its glossing over of the existing land use process, a nagging problem with redundancies in the text and its calls for change without specifics commonly found in academic tracts, Drosscape offers a wonderful overview of the state of affairs in modern American land use. The vivid pictures alone are worth the price. It also demonstrates once again the power that land use holds over American psyches – even those deep and meaningful psyches that walk the greens of Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Tuesday, November 28, 2006

L.A. Story


This week, after a stay of just over a year, my fiancĂ© and I are packing up and leaving Los Angeles. Based on many factors that work themselves into such an equation, we have decided to move back to our place of origin – New York City. We turn back towards the east, knowing that New York is where we want to be. But as we tape up the final box, I look back at our time here with great affection. I came out here to try my hand at writing for television and film. Although I see it as a success, meeting a number of wonderful people, and I intend to continue my pursuit in New York, I did not “make a sale” while here. But the other learning experience I had while living in Los Angeles was the ability to enjoy a first hand experience of one of the most intriguing metropolitan regions on earth from a land use perspective. Los Angeles has always been the model of what not to do when it came to land use planning. Smoggy, sprawly and just plain ugly, pundits, politicians and professors have relegated it to one of the most ill-conceived settlements on earth.

Having driven the freeways, breathed the air, walked the beaches and explored its canyons, I leave this place better educated about why people continue to move here and grow this behemoth of a metropolitan area. Sure, the driving is terrible. The drivers, in fact, are even worse. There are days when it’s difficult to breathe (especially if you’re sensitive to bad air like I am). When it rains around here, the television meteorologists declare a state of emergency. Not having seasons does make you got nuts. The Los Angeles Times devotes a week’s worth of front page space to a celebrity (oh, let’s say Mel Gibson for instance) who gets stopped for having a few too many drinks. And yes, there is more silicone here than the Sahara Desert. But underneath the lunacy that defines Los Angeles is an environment that adds up to an oddly, but extremely, livable place.

Any observer of the urban condition will tell you that the key to a successful community is creating pedestrian-scale neighborhoods patched together by a collective sense of ownership. The very old joke in L.A. is that no one walks. For the most part, this is true. But nonetheless, “Los Angeles,” as constituted, is a patchwork of neighborhoods, one that blends into the next. If you travel down Sunset Boulevard, moving from the water inland, you weave through a multiplicity of different and distinct areas. Pacific Palisades leads to Brentwood. Cross over the 405 freeway and enter Westwood, which passes along the entrance to Bel Air, which evolves to Beverly Hills, which morphs into West Hollywood, which changes over to Hollywood, and so on, and so forth. You can take any path across the gigantic Los Angeles basin and find yourself traversing through a constant turnover in neighborhood after neighborhood, each with its own character and collection of denizens. The beach is very different from the Valley, the Hills provide a vast departure from Pasadena. The list and comparisons are like an old Love Connection episode, where each pair discusses how far apart the two of them live, all in the interest of dinner and a movie.

Depending on which numbers you believe, the Los Angeles metropolitan region is the densest area in the United States. The sprawl has morphed into really dense sprawl. In the process, the inhabitants have forged for themselves a place to live comfortably, for the most part. Los Angeles offers the wonderful escapes of beaches and forest, winter and summer sports all at the same time. And the places where people spend most of their time in a given year, although clogged with traffic, still provides a spot on an individual level, even to walk around once in awhile. Therefore, even though it’s time to leave, our time in L.A. was extremely well spent.

Tuesday, November 21, 2006

Let's Give Thanks


During the week of this most gluttonous of holidays, we should reflect on the meaning of the event in the context of land use. Most conversations on land use assume the modern-day axiom that there is no further question as to the legitimacy of “Americans” on the soil they call home. The question isn’t so much who owns the property but rather, what will be done to said tract. Yes, the well-worn story of European aggression leading to the wresting of the North American continent from native peoples underlies this query. But where does this narrative stand today?

An intriguing story comes from upstate New York, the home of the Oneida Indian Nation. The Nation has grown in stature, with the aid of profits generated by its Turning Stone Casino and Resort complex just off the New York Thruway, about an hour’s drive east of Syracuse. Its economic strength has also increased its political clout in the region, something that is not always welcomed by the other inhabitants of the area, who make up about 99% of the population. In March, 2005, the United States Supreme Court, in City of Sherill v. Oneida Indian Nation of New York, held that the Nation, which attempted to reacquire ancestral lands and reintegrate these new purchases into the autonomous lands of their tribe, still had to pay property taxes on these new tracts. The Court reasoned because the Oneidas had waited so long to reassert authority over these lands, they could not use the tax exemption that would typically apply. Moreover, the Court was concerned that if the Oneidas were allowed to reassert control over their recent purchases, the Nation could also claim that it was not subject to local zoning requirements that the non-Nation properties still face.

The decision is not the end of the story. The Nation responded to the adverse decision by filing with the United States Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) an application for the territory at issue to be taken into trust, which would have the same effect as being declared sovereign territory. Senator Charles Schumer has voiced his alignment with the impacted localities against the Nation. “Simply put, where no legitimate land claim exists, the BIA should be very hesitant to reward tribes – and harm counties and municipalities – by placing non-contiguous land into federal trust.”

From a land use perspective, having the localities remain sovereign over the new Oneida lands on its face appears to make sense. Consistency of application is a rule common to the American experience. But doesn’t it seem a little disingenuous to have the Supreme Court and Senator Schumer side with the municipalities on the bases of fair play and other equitable justifications? Who has been harmed more over the course of the last five hundred years? As always, the issue is less about history and more about the almighty dollar. Jealous of the Oneida’s successes, both the local and state governments cringe over the potential tax revenues that would be lost if all of the Nation’s earnings were free from levy. Tax revenues are always a factor in the land use calculus. Municipalities are always on the prowl for the all-important “ratables.”

But in this case, there is more at play than a question of money. Sovereignty and home rule are precepts that municipalities continue to fight to preserve in the face of regionalization. This very same fundamental right is what the Oneidas are seeking. The land use process is part of the self governance equation, and would not be ignored by the Nation, as it has not been on the property that currently falls within the tribe’s control. At this time of year, when we can reflect on the origins of our ritual of turkey and football, isn’t it worthwhile to think about the importance of thanks, and sharing, after all that has come before?

Wednesday, November 15, 2006

The Future!


This Friday, after a four-year hiatus, the James Bond franchise returns to the silver screen with Casino Royale, the original story from Bond’s creator, Ian Fleming, and a new fellow filling the tuxedo, Daniel Craig. I look forward to it with great anticipation. But what does this have to do with land use, you ask? Well, aside from the commercials depicting a fight scene atop a half-completed skyscraper, the return of Bond got me to thinking about the role of film and television in portraying the land use process, and if, along with the high profile of Kelo, has the mass media portrayed it accurately, or with sufficient care? Professionals, and those in “the know” often complain how Hollywood distorts the “truth” of their vocation. Surgeons look for egregious mistakes in operating room scenes, psychologists scoff at laughable therapy sessions, and police officers cringe at shoddy techniques employed by those who only “play them on T.V.”

The crooked land developer is a common villain, from the shady fellow who built on old Indian burial grounds in Poltergeist, to just about every bad guy who uttered the line “if it wasn’t for those pesky kids” on Scooby-Doo. In a more recent example, John Sayles, a respected independent film director, made Sunshine State, an ensemble piece analyzing the personal and political dynamics of a proposed development in a coastal Florida town. The film even throws in a few board hearing scenes to provide a pretty solid picture of the process. Finding examples of land use-themed fiction is not hard. Finding memorable ones is more of a challenge.

Luckily, one of the greatest villains of all time, in one of the greatest movies of all time happens to be a land baron: Noah Cross in Chinatown. Loosely based on the real-life water grab from the Owens Valley to usher in modern Los Angeles, Chinatown is the greatest portrayal of land use to date because it captures the personality and politics behind the process. Early in the film, Jack Nicholson, as smarmy private investigator J.J. Gittes, begins his investigation of a suspected philandering husband at a City Council meeting. He eyes his prey while the drama of the meeting occurs around him. The talk is of water, and how the city needs it to grow. Unhappy ranchers from the region’s outskirts make their point for a new aqueduct from the Owens Valley by running a herd of sheep down the council chambers’ aisles, demanding water for their livestock. Gittes yawns, but we see the messy process at work.

Behind the push for water is Noah Cross, played by the renowned director John Huston. From Cross, Gittes, and the audience, learn the true importance of the water scheme. As Cross explains, “Either you bring the water to L.A. or you bring L.A. to the water.” Gittes probes deeper, wonders why a fabulously rich man like Cross would want to get involved in something as mundane as water. “The future, Mr. Gittes. The future!” In that one line, the film captures what it is that makes land use such a critical part of our democratic system. What we want to be, and how we want ourselves to look, largely depends on the decisions we make in land use meetings across the nation. The power of Chinatown, as the quintessential land use film, resides in the simplicity of Noah Cross’s words.

Of course there are other examples out there, and I invite comment on your favorite depictions of land use in fiction. At the bottom of it all, I’m just thankful that Bond is back. Speaking of being thankful, next week is a holiday designed to do just that. We’ll take a look at the celebration, in the context of land use.